8
free will. Her behavior is rather devilish, as Christians would have viewed her to be,
26
but
even with this added behavior, she aids in the revelation of sin and the destruction of
worldly possessions, thus helping mortals approach a deeper relationship with the
Christian God. Some may disagree with this idea, especially followers of Augustine and
Aquinas, since both men contradict Boethius, claiming the word “fate” is not to be used
and is not acceptable in Christian texts.
27
It was Augustine especially who claimed that,
“through [human] free-will, individuals made choices, which God either punished or
rewarded, in his justice and his mercy.”
28
Augustine clearly supports the notion that there
is only one supreme power; even Boethius, at first, confirms the idea that only God
maintains control of the universe since God needs no external assistance,
29
but then he
also contradicts himself by offering the idea that fate is actually God’s Providence:
“Providence includes all things at the same time, however diverse or infinite,
while Fate controls the motion of different individual things in different places
and in different times. So this unfolding of the plan in time when brought
together as a unified whole in the foresight of God’s mind is Providence; and the
same unified whole when dissolved and unfolded in the course of time is Fate.
“They are different, but the one depends on the other. The order of Fate is derived
from the simplicity of Providence.”
30
26
Patch 16. He notes here, “The Goddess is more or less identified with the spirit of evil.”
27
For a more thorough discussion of the view of Boethius, see Adrian Papahagi, “Hic Magis Philosophice
Quam Catholice Loquitur: The Reception of Boethian Platonism in the Carolingian Age.” Boethiana
Medievalia: A Collection of Studies on the Early Medieval Fortune of Boethius’ Consolation of Philosophy.
(Bucharest, Zeta Books, 2010) 37-72.
28
See Marilyn Corrie. “‘God May Well Fordo Desteny’: Dealing with Fate, Destiny, and Fortune in Sir
Thomas Malory’s Le Morte Darthur and Other Late Medieval Writing.” Studies in Philology 110.4 (2013):
690-713, especially 693.
29
See Boethius Book III, Section XII, 115, in which Philosophy states, “In regulating the universe He will
need no external assistance – otherwise, if He needs anything, He won’t have complete sufficiency.”
30
See Boethius Book IV, Section VI, 141.